Tuesday, February 10, 2009

billions and billions.

Everything morally right derives from one of four sources: it concerns either full perception or intelligent development of what is true; or the preservation of organized society, where every man is rendered his due and all obligations are faithfully discharged; or the greatness and strength of a noble, invincible spirit; or order and moderation in everything said and done , whereby temperance and self-control.
~ Cicero, De Officiis, I, 5 (45-44 BC)

(This is from a conversation had late a while back in which I could not articulate very well and so I am finally getting to writing the thoughts out that I could not seem to come up with at that time).

We take for granted the fact that our civilization lives by a set of rules. More so, moral codes, which beg the questions: what does it mean to do the right thing? Should we help a stranger in need? How do we deal with someone who is not very nice to us? Should we ever exploit someone who treats us kindly? If hurt by a friend or helped by an enemy, should we repay in kind or does any past behaviour outweigh recent departures from the status quo?

We probably come across these questions – or forms of them – much more often than we might initially think. Human behaviour is complex, so are there any hard and fast rules in which to apply to any of these scenarios? Of course not, because of our complexity. So then, how do we decide what to do? Knowing how to behave is a part of being wise.

Over the course of human history, we have devised a set of rules in which to apply. Each one varies rather significantly, and it is only recently that we have attempted – scientifically, anyway – to show which one or ones works most often. Granted, this is not an exact science.

The first rule is often termed the Golden Rule, and is this: do unto others as you would have them do unto you. That probably sounds familiar. We all know that rule. None of us actually follows it. Or at least hardly any of us. Why don't we follow this simple and enlightened rule? Because it does not take into account any of our differences and ultimately it is a losing proposition (keep reading, or not .... )

So we devised a Silver Rule, which is: do not do unto others what you would not have them do unto you. Two notable examples of followers of this rule are of course Ghandi and MLK, Jr. It was their mission to tell others not to repay violence with violence, but not to be compliant either. For their followers to show, through civil disobedience, their defiance to a certain law or injustice. But even Ghandi admitted that "I have not the qualifications for teaching my philosophy of life. I have barely the qualifications for practicing the philosophy I believe. I am but a poor struggling soul yearning to be wholly truthful and wholly nonviolent in thought, word and deed, but ever failing to reach the ideal."

So we devised a Brass Rule, which is: do unto others as they do unto you. "Repay kindness with kindness, but evil with justice," said Confucius. Put another way, it says "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth." This is the most common human behaviour, whether or not we want to admit it. But is it true or not that two wrongs do not make a right?

So we devised the Iron Rule, which is: do unto others as you like, before they do it unto you. This rule is one often followed by (surprise!) those in power, as it seems to openly shun the Golden Rule. There are far too many examples of this behaviour found throughout our all-too-short history.

So that begs the question: which one is right? Is the most commonly-followed rule the most flawed? It can be easily discerned that the Brass Rule can perpetuate many, many atrocities – both on a small scale as well as a global scale. The Iron Rule seems to promote the advantage of a ruthless and powerful few against the interests of everyone else. But on the other hand, aren't the Golden and Silver Rules, well, too nice because they do not punish cruelty and exploitation of others? So is any of them right all of the time, or must we always analyze a situation before applying a rule to its outcome?

Like I mentioned, we have just recently begun to study this from a scientific perspective. We are used to playing games where one person wins and everyone else loses. It's natural. We grew up learning these games. In these kinds of games, the losses end up balancing out the wins so they are known as "zero-sum" games. There's no grey area – your opponent will do everything in their power to beat you (assumingly within the rules of the game). Take Monopoly, for example – there is no way to play that game cooperatively for the betterment of all. Sounds ridiculous, right? That's not how it is designed. Someone – just one – always wins. So the only rule that we have defined above that applies to these zero-sum games is the Iron Rule. So that begs the question now, that if the Golden (or even the Silver) Rule is so highly revered, why is it rarely practiced?

However, there are different games – or scenarios. Take the ravaging of the environment, for example. Does one side win by doing this? Of course not, we both lose – us and it. And on the flip-side, what about giving to someone in need? We feel good and those we gave too do as well – this is win-win.

So there are three different scenarios then in which we can apply our four rules. The scientific field that deals with experimenting with the outcomes by applying different rules (or strategies) is known as game theory, and it is used in many different fields (from playing the stock market to military exploits and so forth). The paradigm is a game called the Prisoner's Dilemma (the funny thing is I had a very wise assistant principal in junior high who applied this fascinating theory on my good friend and me – I will not divulge our crime). It is not at all a zero-sum game, as all three scenarios are possible when played out. It works like this: suppose you and a friend are arrested for committing a crime of some sort. It does not matter if either, neither or both of you are guilty. What matters only is that the police (or, um, your vice principal) thinks you did it. And before the two of you can get your stories straight (exactly!), you are interrogated separately (genius, that Mr. Lacey).

So what happens? Well, the police of course tell you that your friend has confessed and implicated you. They may or may not be telling the truth. You can of course only plead innocent or guilty (claiming "I don't know" does not really work here). So, what do you do? You think quickly of the outcomes:

1) You deny everything and so does your friend (although you don't know that they have) so the case is hard to prove and you both get off.
2) You confess and so does your friend, so the case is easy to prove and you both get a light sentence but neither of you are off scott-free.
3) You plead innocent but your friend confesses, so he gets off with a lighter punishment and you get raked over the coals (this is of course called a double-cross). And then you're grounded for I cannot remember how long. Uh, nevermind.

So if you both cooperate – meaning you either both confess or deny – you both escape the worst. So should you play it safe and guarantee a middle-of-the-road punishment by confessing? Too bad for your friend if he pleads innocent, right? Uh, sorry Jim. When you have had a minute to think about it and you're not some scheming little seventh grader, you realize that whatever your friend does you're better off defecting (doing the opposite) than cooperating (doing the same). Um, but of course the same holds true for them. But, um, if you both defect you're both worse off than had you both cooperated. This is the dilemma ....

Once you've sorted that out, consider if you will a repeated Prisoner's Dilemma where you go through a sequence of these games. Kind of like what we do subconsciously (or consciously) on a daily basis when faced with a situation in which we must decide for ourselves what is the "right" thing to do. And this of course happens over time – the whole of human history, say. Will the two people learn to cooperate game after game, both always denying or admitting their guilt? What if you cooperate too much, will your friend exploit your vulnerability? But if you defect too much, won't your friend end up defecting as much, which is bad for both of you? What is the right mix of defection vs. cooperation?

This has been studied of course over time, and the simplest strategies are thus to either always cooperate, no matter how much advantage is taken of you, or always defect, no matter the fact that there are benefits to cooperating. These are the Golden and Iron Rules, respectively. The key that can be discerned here is that they always lose (in the sense of the resulting punishment over time), the one from always being nice, the other from always being ruthless. So should you defect at first, but if your friend (or opponent) cooperates just once, then you cooperate in all future games? Or do the opposite? Well, those also lose because, unlike in zero-sum games, you cannot rely on your opponent to be always out to get you (unless perhaps they are some sort of sociopath).

So the answer is (this is probably a pretty long post so if you've made it this far props) .... it's simple: "quid pro quo." Meaning, in the effort of goodwill you start out cooperating, and in each successive round you just do what your friend did the last round. You punish a defection by defecting, but once they cooperate, you're willing to let that be water under the bridge and you move on back to cooperating. As time goes on and the game is repeated ad infinitum (and other strategies have defeated themselves from being too kind or too mean) you pull ahead and you're only grounded for an afternoon or so. So what rule does this equate (which is ultimately the answer, I think)?

Wait for it .... the Brass Rule (which, since it's way back up there, is "do unto others as they do unto you").

This is a surprisingly simple game, as it must be in order to test the different theories. Real life is of course much more complex. So what does this mean? Do random acts of kindness – if widespread – improve us all? So it would seem. It also seems the lessons learned from this dilemma are ones about the self-defeating nature of envy, and perhaps of the importance of long-term vs. short term goals (the winning strategy does not appear to win at first, but only over time does it prove to do so). I find it extremely interesting.

No wonder I had a hard time recounting that off the top of my head at one o'clock in the morning.

the asphalt world.

OK then. The. Greatest. Pop. Song. Of. All. Time.

Ever.

This is Beethoven's Ninth in D minor for pop music. Parred down from overdubbed guitars and synths and drums and samples and cymbal crashes and drugs to a piano and a cello and his voice in A minor.


Apparently before performing this and leaving, he played The 2 of Us which holds the ranking of the third greatest pop song of all time (okay, maybe second – and of course then second or third is also a Suede song coincidentally from the same album), and before that He's Gone. Someone who was at the theatre commented it was the best three-run song ever. I would have agreed had I made it through. If you really want to hear the nine-and-a-half-minute long album version, buy the vinyl and listen to it on a hi-fi as loud as you can stand. Louder actually. Much much louder.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

climb list 2009.


Gathering beta for climbs and such that I want to do this year and do not want to forget so I am posting them here. I will add to this as I continue to search.

1) Ruth Mountain - the views look staggering – at the über-impressive north face of Shuksan (see, uh, photo at left which pretty much displays in a single photo why the North Cascades are my home and like no other mountain range in the US 48) and into the heart of the southern Picketts, this now tops the list for a spring climb. I'd also love to get into the Picketts (Mt. Spickard comes to mind) but we'll see. Maybe that should get its own bullet point ... Oh, and the climb up the Ruth Glacier looks easy but fun (and those are always good, especially when tossed in the mix with some more ambitious stuff mentioned below).

2) Ptarmigan Traverse – this spectacular, week-long-ish traverse (so we'll see about this one – it would seem it could be done in a few days at a good pace which Matthew and I seem to be able to do pretty consistently) covers some of the most amazing country in all of the North Cascades. It starts at the esteemed (and rightly so) Cascade Pass trailhead in the heart of North Cascades National Park and puts you in climbing shot of such peaks as Magic Mountain, Mount Formidable, Dome Peak, Mix-Up Peak and others – all incredible summits. This is definitely quite high on the list.

3) Mount Rainier – Matthew and I will try this most likely via the Kautz Glacier, although if we're super-ambitious we may give a go at the Tahoma Glacier route (although he tried that once and it's a long approach and his group didn't make the summit, so I'm guessing he'll want a more sure-fire way of getting up and as long as we don't do the DC route I'm good). This time – although I loved having climbed this in one go overnight – we'll take two days for acclimatization (which is typically a good thing to have – acclimatization, that is).

4) Stuart Range traverse – let me just say up front ... no plans on duping what Peter Croft did (the entire range in, um, a day after free-soloing the North Ridge route on Stuart – one of the most under-rated but impressive alpine feats of all time). I'll have to look into detailed routes up the north face of Stuart (cos coming from the south, which would be much more doable, means a car is a looong ways away .... however, if Matthew and I each drove, we could easily run up Cascadian Couloir, tag Stuart's summit, then head over for Sherpa, Argonaunt, Colchuck, Dragontail, Annapurna and then – in Croft tradition – jog out Snow Lakes for a burger at the Heidelburger). Hmm, two days – three max I'd like to think. So long weekend, maybe. Sweet. Oh, and here is a good traverse website.

5) The Enchantments – of course. Will go solo and take my chances again on the lottery (knocking on wood now). Must keep further details of this trip highly secretive as to keep down the crowds.

6) Bonanza Peak – this is killer cos the approach entails a trip on the 'Lady of the Lake' ferry on Lake Chelan (in the heart of the North Cascades and super-remote) to the picturesque alpine town of Holden (whose, yes, only approach is via this ferry). Its flanked with glaciers and the views are astounding (from pics I've seen). The climb looks challenging, as well.

7) Sahale Peak – again, this time for the summit instead of twenty-feet below and approaching across Boston Basin and the Quien Sabe glacier for a better chance since it would seem this is the walk-up method (well, after having crossed the glacier). I do love this mountain – it is quite beautiful.

8) Wedge Mountain – quick little scramble just for a unique view into the Enchantments.

9) Cashmere Mountain – this is a possible trip with J later in the summer (West Ridge description here). Mostly for a great view of the entire Stuart range. But also would make a fun little overnight outing, camping at the Caroline Lakes.

10) Whitehorse Mountain – this is an impressive and (granted, this may just be my perception) possibly a rather oft-overlooked peak in the Monte Cristo range of the North Cascades. It has spectacular exposure, a short approach (although lots of elevation gain quickly), glaciers – the works. And it's a beautiful mountain.

OK, will add more later. Like I am still deciding if J and I should go north to the Canadian Rockies or back down to perhaps the Palisades area of the Sierras this summer (in either case, we're either hitting up Silverwood park in Idaho or Magic Mountain in LA for some roller coaster action).

Saturday, February 7, 2009

videotape.

The new song on repeat + repeat + repeat. I have had this record for well over a year and never really listened to it. Until now.

No matter what happens now
I won't be afraid because I know today has been the most perfect day I've ever seen

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

middle c.

A continued study of imperfection and perfection ....

So admittedly I have been researching piano sample sets online. Perhaps out of some morbid fascination I am not sure. Or an innate desire to always have a better sound than I have at my current disposal (the library of samples that came packaged with Logic and my half-tuned in-need-of-restoration Bechstein). Regardless of reason, however, I know full-well that a sampled piano will not be able to physically replicate the sound of a true acoustic piano (and not even taking into account the difference in touch with even the highest end, hammer-weighted actions found on high-end controller keyboards – they simply will not compare to a Renner or Erard action found on a grand piano). The reason, perhaps oddly this time, is actually perfection.

Take for example this scenario: an über-high-end piano sample (meaning made with, say, twelve velocities per note, from pppp to ffff with sustain on and off) can be comprised of more than two thousand samples (88 x 12 x 2 = 2112), at least 80GB of data and require at minimum 4GB of RAM even when using various morphing technologies that allow offloading of processing power based on samples actually used – not entirely unlike MPEG compression albeit slightly different in theory) but – and this is key – it falls apart reproducing what an acoustic piano does naturally – overtones. The necessary processing power to replicate even the simplest set of overtones is at least to-date challenging (and yes, I realize a new Mac Pro for instance can be stuffed with 16GB of RAM – but I want to say there is actually a degradation in performance when using too much RAM? – but the aforementioned 4GB of RAM is simply to reproduce the given samples on their own, not taking into account the overtones of multiple sampled notes, which is why I chose the word "challenging").

But just pluck a string (of fixed length) and you get overtones. No RAM required. Perfection. Mathematical anyway, as they are integer multiples of the fundamental frequency.

Take Middle C (actually, we'll use the C an octave below as our fundamental – known as C3 on the piano – thus placing Middle C as the second harmonic of the fundamental which is always an octave above or 2x the fundamental frequency). This string, when the piano is tuned to concert pitch, vibrates at 131 cycles per second (actually, 130.81Hz but I will round up for simplicity). The second fundamental – as stated – is 2x that frequency, or 262Hz (Middle C/C4). The third harmonic is 3x the fundamental, or 393Hz (the G above Middle C, or a 5th above C4 – same thing). The fourth harmonic is 524Hz, or C5 – two octaves above the fundamental or a fourth above the third harmonic). The fifth is 655Hz, or E5 (a third above C5). The sixth – 786Hz, or a 5th above C5 (notice how the 4th, 5th and 6th harmonics form a C major chord two octaves above the fundamental C?). The seventh overtone is tricky – it produces an unwanted note due to physics and harmony. But in our unfound wisdom we have devised a cunning scheme to avoid it on the piano by placing the hammers near the 7th node of the speaking length of the strings (a node is a point along a string where it does not vibrate – so by dividing the length of the strings by 7 and placing the hammers at a distance of 1/7th the length of the string – approximately – this overtone is avoided – mostly, and since it is an overtone and reduced by this placement it is basically not heard). Brilliant. And I'll avoid the elaboration of why this is to be avoided, but basically it is a very flat minor seventh (hence, the division by 7 of the string length) of the fundamental and does not sound harmonious.

OK, I realize I could continue that ad infinitum but in any regards – the overtones are mathematical and thus perfect. However, they create dissonance (in other words, an imperfection). The key is that there is good dissonance (a diminished chord, for example) and there is bad dissonance (a flat minor-seventh), so-to-speak. In the case of harmonics, dissonance is absolutely necessary. For it is in this very dissonance that what is known as timbre is created (subtle, but yet another example where imperfection is necessary). And timbre is loosely-defined as "the quality of a musical note or sound that distinguishes it from another." It is what allows us to tell the difference between a guitar and a harp. Or a trombone and a tuba. Or a Bechstein and a Bösendorfer. And as hard as engineers have tried, the dissonance and thus imperfection resulting from the near-perfect mathematical equations going on with a struck string, let alone ten or twelve or twenty all vibrating at once, is not possible with digital samples.

At least not yet. Perhaps someday, but that really is beside the point. I still am refusing to drag myself into an analog vs. digital debate. To each their own. But as I listen to high-end sample after high-end sample of some of the finest pianos in the world meticulously recorded in elaborate studios and then go back to hammering away on my Bechstein, the coloration of the sound (hence, the timbre of all the overtones) is much more intense than what can currently be achieved with sampled instruments.

And with that I digress ....

Monday, February 2, 2009

bechstein.

Somehow I missed this, but apparently in the fall of 2006 Bechstein "came" to America (and now have a website that does not require on-the-fly translation from German in order to view) when they reacquired the shares then-owned by the Korean manufacturer Samick and selected for their North America flagship showroom a facility within blocks of Carnegie Hall and Lincoln Center. This is huge, as prior to this distribution in the US was sparse to non-existent and these most incredible of instruments were difficult if not impossible to come by.

I have fired off an email in excitement inquiring as to the possibility and expense of having my Bechstein A reconditioned either in Berlin at the factory or who knows – perhaps now in New York by Bechstein craftsmen? A reply is guaranteed by my "Bechstein America Team" – and I wait in eagerness. I cannot hardly imagine the sound this piano sitting next to me will make when fully restored. Overwhelming.

Of course, since the day I got it I have pined for an even larger piano (the Model A is 6'1" in length) – a Model C 7'7" would be most spectacular and would no doubt simply overpower my living room but that is not the point. It is all about volume because I must always play louder louder LOUDER .... (of course larger pianos also have longer keysets so subtle playing is easier had on these instruments).

Sunday, February 1, 2009

the human potential.

This thought occurred to me just now after having seen a newscast last week where the Bush daughters had left a letter for the Obama girls – a sort of 'things to remember about your Dad during the time you grow up under such incredible circumstances' sort of letter. The Bush girls were talking about their father and how to them he was only their father – not the President or the man the rest of us saw – and during the voiceover the broadcast was flashing pictures of the Bush family. The one that caught my attention was the one of George W. holding one of his newborn daughters for the first time. And in an instant I had forgotten what atrocities that man had obliged during his term in office, the apparent loss of morals and ethics he showed with which all human beings are naturally born.

And it occurred to me that in that photograph – and any photograph of a parent holding their child for the first time – that in that moment, that instant, lies the entire human potential. Because in that moment we all are identical, regardless of any circumstance. We are selfless. We are small. We are worried. We are frightened. We are brave. We are strong. We are excited. We are wise. We are hopeful.